Question details

asked in:
39925
wrestlingfan420
wrestlingfan420 (Rank: Bachelor)

What does the rest of the world think about America and Americans????

I think I have a pretty good idea where this is going to go, but I would like your opinions anyway. I currently live in America and I was born in America. I love America and I love what America stands for. That is pretty much where my love affair with my home country stops. First of all, our 'President' George Bush is the biggest piece of garbage I have ever seen in my 31 years on this planet. He has single-handedly ruined this country's economy due to his conflict's of interest with oil. The President of the United States owns more than half of then oil wells in Texas and with the current state of gas prices being what they are, would everyone not agree that it is a huge conflict of interest? He has the power to enact legislation to try and regulate the sharp increase in gas prices, but why would he? That is money out of his pocket!!! It just makes me sick!!! That is all I have to say about Bush. What are your opinions, if any, on Bush? As far as Americans go, I know what most of the rest of the world thinks about most Americans. We are lazy, arrogant, disrespectful, and we are an embarrassment to our country. And you know what, for the most part, you are absolutely right!!! I am embarrassed sometimes to be an American given the reputation we have with the rest of the world. We have more problems in the US than I ever hear about in Europe or anywhere else. I am not embarrassed to be an American per se, I am embarrassed about how Americans are perceived by the rest of the world. That is part of the reason I am on here, to get fresh opinions from people on the outside looking in because as far as my friends are concerned, America is the end-all, be-all society of the world. What do you think about Americans? Do you have any American friends? Do they feel like me? I appreciate any answers even if they are not in agreeance with my views!!!

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
2

helpful

credits: 50
Asked in Politics, Economics, Opinions asked on: 07/09/2008 02:23pm
closed on: 07/09/2008 06:24pm

6 Answers

624
CGA

CGA

Rank: Robert Koch (8,315) | politics (163), opinions (80), Economics (6)

25 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 02:47pm)

1

This question is a biggy. The real answer is that the rest of the world, just like Americans, has a range of opinions from extremely supportive to extremely critical. A lot will depend on the Americans that you have come into contact with (if any).
It is true that there are certain stereotypes for Americans, that are probably true in some cases but not as widely as people think.
So lets look what is behind these :-

1) America is the largest world power and affects everybody else in the world. Naturally, this is resented by many. This leads to charges that Americans are too arrogant and full of their own importance.

2) The standard American annual holiday is much shorter than that in Europe (and many other places). This, added to the fact that America is a very large & diverse country, means that many never travel outside it's borders (except in the army). As a result, many feel that Americans are somewhat insular in their outlook.

3. American forces have abroad have been rather well paid in relation to the communities they have been living in. This has caused a certain amount of friction in the past that has not always been helped by the fact that many GI's were not always the best ambassadors for the US. In WWII the common complaint about GI's was that they were "overpaid, oversexed & over here".

4. Many of the Americans that are able to travel tend to be quite wealthy and have a reputation of feeling that their behaviour does not matter if they have sufficient money to buy what they want.

I know that this all makes me sound very anti-American, which I am not. I have many American friends (both here in Germany and in the States) that I know to be very different to this. I also know that there are huge numbers of Americans that we never see that are not at all wealthy.

What I do think is there is a fine line between pride and arrogance and sometimes it does seem as if this is crossed.

Stereotypes always have some foundation in truth but are more accurate in exception than the rule.

Of course, having a leader like GWB does not help - but there are many other countries where the citizens can have similar doubts about their leader.


Supplement from 07/09/2008 03:13pm:

I have to agree with Siasl about the fact that the Americans that I have dealings with may not be an accurate sample set. Although I do not work for an American company, I do have almost daily contact with a supplier company in the States and a weekly conference call. These people are always pleasant, courteous and intelligent - but you would expect this as they professional technicians.

I should have added that you should never be ashamed of your nationality because of the way others behave. Reasonable people will judge you by what you are and you have the change of being a good ambassador to add new facets to peoples opinions of Americans.

Question owner's rating:

Top

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
2

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

20936
siasl74

siasl74

Rank: Albert Einstein (18,302) | politics (177), opinions (116), Economics (19)

35 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 02:58pm)

2

On an individual level, I've not met many americans who weren't genuinely nice people. I work for an american company, and pretty much every day I'm on conference calls with them, so I've met a fair few. On the other hand, the set of americans I have met are drawn from the very well educated set of americans so I can understand if there is some bias in my "sample set".

I've been over there a few times and not met any oiks either. So, I can quite readily admit that the populace in general is probably much the same as those around the world - there's nice folks, and there's not-nice folks.

On the other hand, the americans that are exported by the busload as tourists can have a tendency to stick out like sore thumbs in the UK - and that does your nation no favours. I seem to recall that the US tourism bureau (whatever it might be called) has even published an official guide on how to blend in a bit better and not offend folks (although I can possibly imagine that this guide is a bit of a mickey-taking out of foreign perceptions of american tourists).

I think part of the issue is that if you stick a bunch of average americans, british, canadian, australian & New Zealanders in a room, while they can all talk together perfectly adequately by virtue of having a common language - even if some folks do mangle the spellings :-) - the differences between cultures will be accentuated because of this.

And no, GWB doesn't help things :-) It will be interesting if the Democrats in San Francisco get their way and name the sewerage plant after him when he leaves office. I hear the Republicans are somewhat offended :-)

Question owner's rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
2

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

3

3 Different opinions

38111
robinsamuels

robinsamuels

Rank: PhD (2,651) | politics (50), opinions (33)

56 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 03:18pm)

3

Careful mate, look what happened to the Dixie Chicks!

I think that the main problem is one of arrogance. Not in any individual way, but as a country in general. I don't mean that as an insult, but more as a sort of slightly ass-backwards compliment.

The US constitution is one of the best pieces of legislation ever written and the political system that it has spawned is one of the strongest. The problem is that there is a tendency to see this as justifying an attitude that goes something along the lines of: "look at how successful we are, if you take on our system you will be a great country and our ally, if you don't you're our enemy and will fail". What I heard one political commentator in the US describe as "Democratic Fundamentalism".

The whole world does not have to have the same system or beliefs as the US and the sooner you have a government which acknowledges these differences, the sooner the country will again become accepted by the world at large.

Question owner's rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
0

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

2

2 Different opinions

33970
Family.Guy

Family.Guy

Rank: Nobel Prize Winner (5,672) | opinions (42), politics (22)

59 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 03:22pm)

4

Personally i have met a few Americans and those particular ones were so loud and in your face and patronising you just wanted to punch them! and their whining voices just went right through you it was horrible to meet them. However saying that this was only a handful of Americans so i cant judge the rest of America on those experiences as everyone are different. I assume there are a lot of nice Americans i just have not met them yet that's all.
the things i hate about America is their government especially G.Bush JNR and how he has screwed the world over with his actions.
Another thing i hate is the overwhelming patriotism the American displays you said it your self your not ashamed of being American ! well you should be, If it wasn't for the majority voting in that idiot he wouldn't of got in power. All my problems with America are all political, Im sure there are a few nice American people around for example Drew Barrymore ( drools )


Supplement from 07/09/2008 03:27pm:

I would also like to add there is a film called 'Sicko' about the healthcare provisions you make there was one woman who was in a car accident and because she didn't pre approve the Ambulance with the insurance company she was billed. and it is really disgusting how the volunteer rescue workers are treated by being billed for helping at 911 if i was American i would be very ashamed of my country.

Question owner's rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
0

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

3

3 Different opinions

10111
englishdanny

englishdanny

Rank: Doctorate (2,121) | politics (10), opinions (8), Economics (5)

94 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 03:56pm)

5

I think that the impression that Americans are resented because of thier wealth and freedoms has always being a bit of a myth. I've travelled quite a bit and worked in about 12 different countries.

I've not found this to be the case. Most people admire different aspects of America and although maybe irritated by loud tourists in European museums and cathedrals this rarely goes as far as resentment.

I was a bad boy at school so I self educated and took private courses. I decided to study both US and UK English and grammar and was well impressed by US dictionaries and other sources of reference. There is simply no way anyone could say US English was any less advanced or as sophisticated than good old Oxford English!

The main problem in recent times has been the globally destabilising effect of a militaristic foreign policy that alarms and concerns just about everyone else.

The record oil prices which are hurting everyone are in some part caused by the US government making threats against Iran. A study of the consequences of any attack clearly show that only a total mad man would even consider this! That scares everybody.

I never had a sense that hard working Americans are blamed for this. I think that a lot of people around the world are concerned that your government is a bit out of control and may have been somehow hi-jacked by "the crazies from the basement".

Polls show that a majority of Americans disapprove of government actions and US congress currently has an 11% approval rating.

In the UK we have Gordon Brown another deeply unpopular lame duck leader. In Europe the EU constitution has been thrown out 3 out of 3 times by EU countries that had a referendum indicating a deep mistrust amongst ordinary citizens of the EU leadership.

Although we are in different boats, so to speak, in many ways the problems are fairly similar.

I spent a month in the Middle East at the beginning of the year and the whole region is in trauma compared with what it used to be like.
Even there, with highly elevated tensions, I never heard any anti Americanism that was directed at the ordinary US citizen.


Supplement from 07/09/2008 04:24pm:

Latent Thought: It's not the schoolkids that are the problem. It's the bullies who have taken over the playground! Thanks for a great question.

Question owner's rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
1

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

4035
Candy.DeRun

Candy.DeRun

Rank: Albert Einstein (15,242) | politics (124), opinions (76), Economics (16)

118 minutes after the question was opened (07/09/2008 04:20pm)

6

First one point Americans (and America) include Canadians, Mexicans, Argentineans, Peruvians....
That the question is couched in the form it is (and readilly answered) provides clues as to the potential sources of dis-harmony!

As one who detests patriotism, I will always have a problem with "flag waving" and all attempts to manipulate any group of humans by taking away their capacity for individual thought.I therefor have to take offense at the USA's "success" in this department.

As an example. I believe that most citizens know that the internment situation in Cuba is wrong on all levels, but are forced into compliance by the threat of being "un-American" if they speak out.

I lived for over two years in the USA - including working as a cowboy and lving within the outlaw biker community. I'm proud to include many of its citizens within my global circle of friends.

Given the chance, all people are good - it's only when we force them into nations that the cracks begin to appear.

Question owner's rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
3

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

This question has already been closed. You can write a different opinion to an answer or a comment to this thread.

  • Comments
39925
wrestlingfan420
wrestlingfan420

Great answer!!! This is exactly the type of input I was looking for. I do agree with pretty much everything you had to say. Very well-thought out and masterfully articulated!!! Well done!!!

2232
minx_24.nik
minx_24.nik

In the past i have found a lot of americans to be loud, overbearing and arrogant...then i worked for one as his nanny and found him to be loud, occasionally patronising but on the whole a great bloke :o) I really liked his parents and his niece too. I've been to the USA twice and found everything(in terms of supermarkets and chemists etc)to be bigger but not necessarily better. The hire cars and steaks were outstanding!!!!lol I found the people on the whole to be friendly and polite :o)