Question details

asked in:
14770
Cipher123
Cipher123 (Rank: Master)

How is this possible (I managed to fit 2.05GB of movies on a formatted 1.9GB memory card?!?) - And weird memory issues!

I have a 2GB memory card, which, when formatted, has a final total of 1.9GB. I'm going on holiday in a few days and I've loaded my Archos memory card up with a few movies from my DVD collection to keep me amused. I've ripped them as DivX AVIs, each file being exactly 700mb.

Now, 3 times 700mb = 2.05078125 gigabytes (2.05). Without realising this, I tried to copy all the AVIs onto the card.

A few minutes later once they were all copied, only then did I realise that this shouldn't theoretically be possible. It's branded as a 2GB card, and yet I've fitted on more.

I was sort of worried that some error might have happened, I.E. Windows had gotten confused and overwrote other sectors in the memory or something like that. I right clicked the drive, and did "Repair" or something to check it was OK, but no errors were found...

So how is this possible? When I look at the drive in Windows Explorer, it says "Capacity: 1.91 GB".

HEY, WAIT A MOMENT... Looking at it now something IS definitely wrong...

The pie chart on Right Click -> Properties shows me that Used Space = 1.01 GB, and the free space is 923MB!

HUH!?!?!?!?!

Now I'll happily suspect something is wrong.

I know all the videos are 700MB, both windows explorer and the Archos media player say that. The memory card is running the FAT file system, hmmm. I've played all the videos, from start to finish (skipping through just to check) and they all play fine... :S

So what's making this happen?

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
0

helpful

credits: 45
Asked in computers, Hardware asked on: 07/19/2008 12:54pm
closed on: 07/26/2008 12:54pm

3 Answers

21627
blacksmith81

blacksmith81

Rank: Albert Einstein (21,006) | computers (157)

79 minutes after the question was opened (07/19/2008 02:13pm)

1

You may not have any problems at all.

A 2GB memory card, will have a total of 2048MB of memory available. What Windows Explorer is seeing is the partition, that has been designated for data storage. a portion of the drive is reserved for control operations.

Many file formats, especially those used for Multimedia files, allow the data to be compressed, hence reducing the space required for storage. This also reduces the screen resolution and size, available for optimum playback.

Rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
1

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

16414
wumpus

wumpus

Rank: Nobel Prize Winner (7,141) | computers (182), Hardware (9)

3 hours after the question was opened (07/19/2008 03:43pm)

2

Could be that compression has been enabled for this drive, meaning that Windows will automatically compress any files that are written to it.

To verify this in XP, right-click on the drive and select properties.

Somewhere near the bottom of the "General" tab, there's a check box entitled "compress drive to save disk space".

If this is checked, it explains everything.

As a bonus, you've got space for even more movies!

Rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
1

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

20936
siasl74

siasl74

Rank: Albert Einstein (18,920) | computers (1,381), Hardware (15)

46 hours after the question was opened (07/21/2008 10:42am)

3

Right click on the file, select "Properties" and write down the file size in bytes (call this "A").
Right click on the drive letter for the USB stick, select properties, and write down the capacity in Bytes (call this "B").

I would expect A to be less than B - unless you are using compression. Comparing megabytes and gigabytes is usually futile as different folks use different methods of defining what they mean.

SI units mean that a mega-X is one million of X, and a giga-X is one billion of it. In computers, however, a "megabyte" is 1024x1024 = 1,048,576 Bytes. A gigabyte multiplies by another 1024 - however some computing applications quantify things in SI units, rather than computing units. I seem to recall some hard drive vendor got their wrists slapped for this as it artificially inflated the stated size of their drives.

Rating:

helpful

Rated as good answer by:

supporters so far (last 10):

[Close window]
0

Rate as good answer

Number of comments:

0

Add your opinion

This question has already been closed. You can write a different opinion to an answer or a comment to this thread.

  • Comments